A new food index has labeled 36 meat and fish suppliers as “high risk” for public market investors because they fail to manage critical business risks such as greenhouse gas emissions and antibiotics risk.
The high-risk companies, worth a combined $152 billion, include major suppliers to McDonalds and KFC, as well as the US’s third-largest poultry producer Sanderson Farms. Brazil’s JBS, which was recently embroiled in a food safety scandal, was also classified as high risk.
The Coller FAIRR Protein Producer Index, which tracks 60 of the world’s largest food companies worth a combined $300 billion, assesses how these companies are managing critical sustainability risks ranging from pollution to the Paris Agreement, and food safety to worker safety.
The FAIRR (Farm Animal Investment Risk & Return) initiative is a collaborative investor network worth $5.9 trillion aiming to educate on the investment risks behind factory farming that was founded by private equity group Coller Capital’s chief investment officer Jeremy Coller.
The food index also reveals the food companies following best practices including “medium risk” US meat producer Tyson Foods, which FAIRR’s accompanying report highlights for the launch of its $150 million venture fund to invest in alternative meat startups and other sustainability-focused technologies. Norwegian aquaculture group Marine Harvest is the top-ranked company, in large part due to its approach to tracking and using antibiotics.
Invest alongside AgFunder in Co-Investment Fund II. Now open for investment. Learn More.
Antibiotic use in the production of meat and fish is a major risk to human health, according to the report, with 77% of companies failing to adequately manage or disclose antibiotic use, despite growing levels of regulation and international action to combat antibiotic-resistant superbugs.
FAIRR also discovered a lack of disclosure when it came to manure management, Aarti Ramachandran, head of research and corporate engagement at the group, told AgFunderNews. Just a quarter of land-based protein companies referenced the management of animal waste at all in their materials, which was surprising considering the increasing scrutiny of manure management and potential for fines in various countries globally, she added.
“Investors need ESG data and transparency to make better investment decisions, yet this information is lacking in the meat, fish and dairy sector. This is the first index to help investors bridge that knowledge gap,” said Coller in a statement. “As megatrends like climate change, antibiotic resistance and food technology radically reshape the way we produce and consume meat, fish and dairy, the Coller FAIRR index will help institutional capital identify both best in class companies and potential stranded assets in the food sector.”
Chinese companies faired the worst with 14 out of 16 in the index classified as high risk although Ramachandran said she was expecting to see low disclosure on ESG from the region.
“One of the key issues we have with some of largest dairy and pork producers in a country like China is that while they are disclosing on some issues, such as pollution, their statistics do not go deep enough to provide the full picture of their impact. For instance with pollution, they might disclose greenhouse gas emissions, but don’t include emissions from enteric fermentation or feed production in beef and dairy,” she said.
The companies in the food index are assessed on eight risk factors, each with underlying KPIs. The risk factors are greenhouse gas emissions, deforestation and biodiversity loss, water scarcity and use, waste and pollution, antibiotics, animal welfare, working conditions, and food safety. More on the methodology can be found the report.
While both Ramachandran and Coller are vegetarians, not everyone in the FAIRR team is. “It’s a real mix but I think it’s fair to say that everyone is interested in sustainable food systems,” said Ramachandran.
Some large asset managers welcomed the index.
“From fast food to fine dining, much of the food on our plates leads back to the livestock and fisheries sector assessed by this Index,” said Abigail Herron, global head of responsible investment at Aviva Investors. “That is why it is of deep concern to investors that a majority of these global food suppliers are failing to manage such significant business risks. On antibiotics alone, FAIRR’s research shows that three in four of these companies are ignoring the calls from regulators, health professionals and the financial community to manage and reduce their use of antibiotics. That failure puts both global public health and their business models at risk.”
Overall Coller FAIRR Protein Producer Index ranking
|Company Legal Name||Market Cap ($bn)||Country||Final Score||
|Marine Harvest ASA||9.894||Norway||82||Low risk|
|Lerøy Seafood Group ASA||3.733||Norway||80||Low risk|
|Bakkafrost P/F||1.860||Faroe Islands||78||Low risk|
|Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd||6.881||New Zealand||69||Low risk|
|Salmar ASA||4.726||Norway||67||Low risk|
|Cranswick PLC||2.120||UK||65||Low risk|
|Charoen Pokphand Foods PCL||6.963||Thailand||65||Low risk|
|Marfrig Global Foods SA||1.162||Brazil||62||Low risk|
|Hormel Foods Corp||17.789||USA||60||Low risk|
|Grieg Seafood ASA||1.035||Norway||55||Medium risk|
|Empresas AquaChile SA||0.580||Chile||53||Medium risk|
|Maple Leaf Foods Inc||2.919||Canada||53||Medium risk|
|Tassal Group Ltd||0.504||Australia||52||Medium risk|
|Grupo Nutresa SA||4.138||Colombia||50||Medium risk|
|Tyson Foods Inc||26.291||USA||49||Medium risk|
|Vietnam Dairy Products JSC||12.938||Vietnam||46||Medium risk|
|Scandi Standard AB||0.426||Sweden||43||Medium risk|
|BRF SA||6.906||Brazil||41||Medium risk|
|JBS S.A.||8.480||Brazil||38||High risk|
|China Shengmu Organic Milk Ltd||0.866||China||38||High risk|
|Pilgrim’s Pride Corp||6.093||USA||38||High risk|
|WH Group Ltd||15.632||China||36||High risk|
|MHP SE||1.458||Ukraine||36||High risk|
|RCL Foods Ltd/South Africa||1.337||South Africa||35||High risk|
|Inner Mongolia Yili Industrial Group Co Ltd||27.029||China||32||High risk|
|NH Foods Ltd||4.386||Japan||31||High risk|
|New Hope Liuhe Co Ltd||4.865||China||30||High risk|
|GFPT PLC||0.534||Thailand||30||High risk|
|QAF Ltd||0.416||Singapore||28||High risk|
|China Mengniu Dairy Co Ltd||18.555||China||28||High risk|
|Beijing Sanyuan Foods Co Ltd||0.944||China||27||High risk|
|COFCO Meat Holdings Ltd||0.631||China||27||High risk|
|LDC SA||2.549||France||26||High risk|
|Inghams Group Ltd||0.993||Australia||25||High risk|
|Nippon Suisan Kaisha Ltd||1.611||Japan||25||High risk|
|Great Wall Enterprises Co Ltd||0.840||Taiwan||24||High risk|
|Henan Shuanghui Investment & Development Co Ltd||13.366||China||22||High risk|
|Sanderson Farms Inc||2.735||USA||20||High risk|
|Shandong Oriental Ocean Sci-Tech Co Ltd||0.910||China||20||High risk|
|Muyuan Foodstuff Co Ltd||8.697||China||19||High risk|
|QL Resources Berhad||2.104||Malaysia||19||High risk|
|Fujian Sunner Development Co Ltd||2.702||China||18||High risk|
|Guangdong Wens Foodstuffs Group Co Ltd||17.537||China||17||High risk|
|Prima Meat Packers Ltd||1.407||Japan||17||High risk|
|Japfa Ltd||0.581||Singapore||16||High risk|
|Almarai Co JSC||14.766||Saudi Arabia||15||High risk|
|Fortune Ng Fung Food Hebei Co Ltd||1.324||China||14||High risk|
|Chuying Agro-pastoral Group Co Ltd||1.110||China||14||High risk|
|China Modern Dairy Holdings Ltd||1.047||China||12||High risk|
|Thaifoods Group PCL||0.705||Thailand||10||High risk|
|Australian Agricultural Co Ltd||0.590||Australia||10||High risk|
|Beijing Shunxin Agriculture Co Ltd||3.622||China||10||High risk|
|Venky’s India Ltd||0.827||India||7||High risk|
|Seaboard Corporation||4.467||USA||7||High risk|
|Cherkizovo Group PJSC||1.232||Russia||5||High risk|
|San Miguel Food and Beverage Inc||2.304||Philippines||5||High risk|
|Industrias Bachoco SAB de CV||3.118||Mexico||5||High risk|
|Cal-Maine Foods Inc||2.280||United States||4||High risk|
|Grupo Bafar SAB de CV||0.657||Mexico||3||High risk|
|Inti Agri Resources Tbk PT||0.532||Indonesia||0||High risk|